Dozens of operators, one journey, and friction at every handover. We examine what it takes to turn a fragmented market into a single experience — from data interoperability and commercial agreements to the areas where public transport doesn’t reach, and the business model nobody has settled yet.
Around the table

Giovanni Dimopoli
Head of Strategy and Business Development, Pluservice and myCicero
Giovanni Dimopoli is Head of Strategy and Business Development at Pluservice and myCicero. An electronic engineer and entrepreneur, he has spent years working on technological innovation applied to mobility, with a particular focus on smart cities, digital services and Mobility as a Service. He has contributed to developing solutions that make mobility more integrated, accessible and connected.

Giulia Serena
Chief of Staff & Head of Strategy Ax Mobility, Moov
Chief of Staff and Head of Strategy Ax Mobility at Moov, where she has followed the development of the group’s strategic projects since its founding stage. A graduate in Management Engineering from Politecnico di Torino, where she also earned an Executive MBA, she has over five years of experience in mobility and in the startup world, working at the intersection of business and technology.

Fabio Steffenino
Head of Technology, Moov
He is Head of Technology at Moov, where he owns the architecture of the group’s mobility and insurance platform and leads the engineering team behind it. A computer engineer, he has spent over twelve years designing technology platforms across travel, real estate, mobility and insurance on three continents, in multinationals, in scale-ups and from scratch.
About this episode
The hardest part of integrated mobility isn’t the technology. In this episode we start from a number that explains a lot: 49% of Italians use their own car every day, the highest share among the 30 countries in the study — and yet 37% say they would give up owning one, rising to 42% among under-35s. We unpack why connecting operators is less a question of APIs than of commercial agreements, why a market with thin margins makes every negotiation harder, and why the MaaS operator’s own business model is still an open question.
We then turn to the places where the model gets tested hardest: inland areas where public transport cannot be economically sustained, and where MaaS cannot create a service that doesn’t exist. From on-demand transport and social car sharing to what MaaS4Italy did and did not solve, the conversation asks what it takes to turn a complex ecosystem into a single simple journey for the person taking it.
Key themes
🔹 Why integration stalls on commercial agreements rather than on technology — and what operators are really afraid of losing
🔹 The three levels of MaaS, from aggregated information to subscriptions and mobility budgets, and why the top level is still fragile
🔹 What happens where public transport doesn’t reach: on-demand services and social car sharing as a way to act on supply, not just on access
🔹 The unresolved business model of the MaaS operator: value created for everyone, remuneration still to be definedThe speed gap between startups that must move fast and institutions built to move slowly
🔹 Ownership versus use: why the car staying essential and people letting go of owning one are not contradictory
Full transcript
What is Mobility as a Service and what is it for?
Mobility as a Service (MaaS) represents a shift in perspective: from owning a vehicle to accessing a mobility service. The aim is to integrate different modes of transport — local public transport, sharing, micromobility, taxis and the car — into a single digital ecosystem, letting users plan, buy and pay for a journey through an experience that is as unified as possible. The novelty is therefore not only technological but cultural: it changes how mobility itself is conceived.
Why does the shift from ownership to use matter so much in MaaS?
A private car sits unused most of the time, while its owner carries the costs of ownership regardless. MaaS starts from the idea that mobility can be organised around how vehicles are actually used rather than around owning them. In that view the car becomes one component of a wider system, alongside public transport, taxis, sharing and other modes.
How does that principle translate into a pay-per-use model?
A pay-per-use model ties the cost of mobility to actual use. Someone who covers more kilometres or uses the service more pays more; someone who uses it less pays less. The aim is to adapt the cost of mobility to a user’s real needs and to place it within a wider mobility budget.
Can MaaS work the same way everywhere in the country?
No. Local context is decisive. Metropolitan areas generally offer more alternatives to the car, while in many non-metropolitan or inland areas public transport and other available modes are not sufficient to replace a private vehicle. There is therefore no single MaaS model: the characteristics and needs of different territories have to be taken into account.
Where does the idea of integrating different mobility operators into one platform come from?
It comes from the need to shift the point of view from supply to demand. Users should not have to know and manage every operator in their area separately. Integration makes it possible to build an experience in which different services can be used through the same digital tools.
What are the main dimensions of integration in MaaS?
There is a horizontal dimension and a vertical one. Horizontal integration means using the same tools, credentials and payment systems across different territories. Vertical integration concerns the ability to combine different modes within the same territory — public transport, taxis, sharing and other services.
What are the different levels of MaaS integration?
A first level concerns infomobility: aggregating information from different services. A second level adds the ability to buy and pay for services directly through the platform. A further level introduces integrated formulas such as subscriptions, packages or mobility budgets, where a user has access to several modes of transport within a single product.
Are package and subscription-based mobility models already established?
Not yet. There are some pilots, particularly in Europe, but the model still has fragile elements and some experiments have not succeeded. Mobility is also a market with relatively thin margins, which makes building economically sustainable models complex.
How can MaaS encourage modal shift?
MaaS can also be used as a public policy instrument to encourage a shift from the car to other modes. Initiatives have been trialled where, for example, people who leave the car at home and commute by public transport receive incentives or cashback. The digital platform becomes a way to support and measure changing mobility habits.
Why can MaaS be considered a digital infrastructure for mobility?
Because it can contribute to modal shift through an infrastructure that is mostly digital, without necessarily requiring the same investment as major physical infrastructure. A platform able to integrate services, information, payments and different modes can make it easier to use alternatives to the car. The limit is that operators have to be willing to integrate into that system.
What is the main technological difficulty in integrating mobility services?
Mobility operators have often grown up with different technology stacks, not designed to talk to one another. Integration therefore requires APIs, access to service availability information, ticket management, payments, refunds, disruption information and customer support handling. That technological complexity has to remain as invisible as possible to the user.
What role does user experience play in MaaS?
Technology has to serve the experience. Users should not perceive the technological complexity behind the service, nor be forced to deal with different operators separately. The real product of MaaS is the simplicity of the experience: a single environment in which to plan a journey, buy the services and handle any problems.
Why can a journey still be too complex digitally today?
A single trip can involve numerous operators and apps: public transport, sharing, parking, tolls, EV charging and other services. Even if each individual app works properly, using several of them together creates friction. MaaS should reduce that fragmentation through an integrated experience, a single account and shared payment systems.
Is technology therefore the main obstacle to MaaS?
Not necessarily. The availability of technology and APIs is still a problem, particularly for smaller and local operators, but the greater difficulty can be commercial and organisational. Integration requires agreements between parties whose interests may differ.
Why might operators be reluctant to integrate into a MaaS ecosystem?
Operators may fear losing the direct relationship with the customer, sharing their data, having their services cannibalised, or having to share revenue with an intermediary. The MaaS operator is perceived as an intermediate party that brings the service to the customer but retains part of the value generated. In a market with thin margins, that makes negotiation particularly complex.
So what is the real challenge of integration between operators?
It is not only connecting different technology systems, but building a sustainable model of collaboration. It takes commercial agreements, rules on data sharing, remuneration mechanisms and a clear definition of roles between operators and MaaS platforms. In many cases the negotiation can be more complex than the technical integration.
How can MaaS work in areas where public transport is insufficient or absent?
MaaS cannot create a transport offering where none exists. Many inland areas are genuine blank spots, where a traditional public transport service is not economically sustainable. In those cases it is necessary to act on supply as well — for example through Demand Responsive Transport, meaning on-demand services.
How could Demand Responsive Transport be integrated into a MaaS system?
Someone living in a small town could use the same platform to book an on-demand service to reach a railway station, continue by train and then use urban public transport. The whole route could be planned and purchased as a single journey, even though it involves different operators and modes.
What other solutions can work in small towns?
Another possibility is social car sharing: sharing a handful of vehicles within the local community. In a small town, a few shared vehicles could be enough to create an alternative to the individually owned car, particularly where traditional public transport cannot cover every need.
How central is the car for Italians today?
The car remains central. According to the figure cited during the webinar, 49% of Italians use their own car every day — the highest share among the 30 countries covered by the Deloitte study referenced in the discussion. At the same time, 37% of Italians say they would be willing to give up car ownership in favour of MaaS; among 18-to-34-year-olds that rises to 42%.
Do those figures mean Italians are ready to give up the car?
Not necessarily. What is changing is above all the relationship between ownership and use. In many parts of Italy the car remains necessary, but among younger generations in particular, owning one is no longer necessarily a goal or an obligatory step. What is growing instead is the attention paid to using whichever mode is most convenient at the time.
Can generational change accelerate MaaS?
Yes. Younger generations appear to weigh flexibility, cost and the actual usefulness of a service more heavily than the symbolic value of owning a car. That does not mean eliminating the car, but changing how it is used within a wider mobility system.
Are public policies already oriented towards this shift from ownership to use?
Not entirely. There are still policies and incentives strongly geared towards buying a car. Supporting this change would require public policy to evolve, so as to do more to encourage the efficient use of different modes and the integration between services.
Is MaaS an alternative to the car, or can it include it?
MaaS should not be seen as the enemy of the car. The car can remain a component of the system, particularly in areas where it is indispensable. But it can be integrated with other modes: a user might drive to a car park and continue by public transport. Parking, tolls and services aimed at drivers can therefore also be part of the MaaS ecosystem.
What was MaaS4Italy?
MaaS4Italy was a national programme funded through the PNRR, involving several Italian metropolitan areas and regions. The project contributed to building a central infrastructure for collecting and connecting data on the mobility offering and — through MaaS operators — on demand as well.
What is the value of a central infrastructure of that kind?
It creates a point of coordination between different parties and makes useful information available to both public administrations and users. In the event of disruption, for instance, information can travel along the chain to the user, allowing the MaaS system to propose alternatives or reorganise the journey.
What came out of the MaaS4Italy pilots?
The pilots gave encouraging signals about the possibility of producing measurable modal shift. They also showed that dialogue can be created between public administrations, local operators and MaaS operators — parties not necessarily used to collaborating within the same ecosystem.
Did MaaS4Italy also solve the economic sustainability of MaaS operators?
No. The programme mainly supported cities and public transport operators in upgrading their infrastructure, while private MaaS operators had to test their own business models independently. One hypothesis was to take a small commission on the value of tickets sold, but with very thin margins economic sustainability remains an open question.
Why is the MaaS operator’s economic model still undefined?
Because the MaaS operator performs an intermediation and aggregation function that creates value for users and operators alike, but has to find a sustainable way of being paid for it. If the commission on individual transactions is very low, it can be difficult to cover the technological, commercial and operational costs of maintaining the integration.
What skills does working in MaaS require?
The sector calls for very different skills. It takes technological skills to develop and integrate platforms, commercial and negotiating skills to build agreements between operators, legal and regulatory expertise, as well as skills in user management and customer service. The very nature of MaaS makes a combination of different competences necessary.
Why is the ability to negotiate particularly important in MaaS?
Because integration between operators is not only a technical matter. Different parties have to be persuaded to share systems, data, customers and revenue. The MaaS operator therefore has to be able to build relationships and agreements between organisations with differing interests and business models.
What is the MaaS operator’s role within the ecosystem?
The MaaS operator performs a function similar to a digital intermediary. It has to connect the user with the available offering, query different operators, assemble the journey and step in when something goes wrong. In the event of disruption it has to be able to propose alternatives and, where possible, re-accommodate the user on other services.
How can AI enter MaaS?
AI fits above all within the technological component and can become one of the tools for managing the complexity of the ecosystem. Its use nonetheless has to be accompanied by attention to legal and regulatory aspects.
What happens to automotive employment if mobility moves from ownership to use?
MaaS does not imply the disappearance of the automotive sector, but it can shift part of the economic value towards the services built around the vehicle and around mobility. Alongside manufacturing the vehicle, what gains importance is the orchestration of services, data, platforms, integration, personalised insurance and managing the user experience.
Does moving from making cars to making mobility services require new skills?
Yes. Some skills will have to be reconverted and others developed. The change involves not only companies but institutions and the education system. Transforming mobility therefore requires professional roles to evolve alongside business models.
What, ultimately, is the most important transformation MaaS introduces?
MaaS does not simply mean replacing the car with other vehicles. It means building an ecosystem in which users can combine different modes according to their needs, using the car when it is needed and turning to alternatives when they are more convenient. The fundamental change is therefore the move from mobility centred on owning a vehicle to mobility centred on access, use and the integration of services.