Open innovation is rewriting the rules, opening the door to partnerships beyond your own industry. How do you pick the right partner — and when is it smarter to say no?
Around the table

Andrea Scalia
Founder & President, Confartigianato Imprese
He is the Head of Innovation, Networks, and Cohesion Projects at Confartigianato Imprese. An expert in innovation and digital transformation, he works to support small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) in their digitization processes and the adoption of new technologies. On behalf of Confartigianato, he collaborates with universities, research centers, academic associations, and entrepreneurial projects.

Matteo Gini
CEO Moov · Host
He is the is Head of Digital Operations at Moov. With almost two decades spent leading large-scale IT projects, he has worked on complex integrated architectures across the energy utility, automotive and insurance sectors, with a particular focus on enterprise architecture and on integration and data architecture. He has led the design and development of web and mobile applications, working with Agile principles and the SCRUM framework.

Gabriele Ratti
CEO Moov · Host
CEO of Moov and host of Moov(er)Time, he guides each conversation toward the practical questions behind the headlines, keeping the focus on what changes for the people who actually move.
About this episode
Partnerships don’t fail because the idea was wrong — they fail because nobody worked out who carries the risk. In this episode we start from an uncomfortable asymmetry: when a large company and a small one collaborate, one tends to impose its processes and the other tends to defend itself, and both reflexes quietly kill the project. We unpack why trust has to come before the contract rather than after it, what symmetry actually means when contributions are unequal, and why open innovation rarely removes complexity — it moves it, from the customer’s side to the orchestrator’s.
We then turn to the companies with the least room for error: SMEs, who cannot build every capability in-house and have to earn their place in an ecosystem through one thing they do better than anyone. From the role of the orchestrator in mobility to AI as both the glue between systems and a potential substitute for the partners it connects, the conversation asks what it takes to build a collaboration that everyone still has a reason to stay in.
Key themes
🔹 Why open innovation moves complexity rather than removing it — and why orchestration is what turns it into simplicity for the customer
🔹 The difference between collaborating for critical mass and collaborating for complementary skills: two models, two very different kinds of value
🔹 Why trust has to come before the contract, and what a contract can never compensate for
🔹 The asymmetry between a large partner and a small one: how imposed processes and defensive reflexes undermine a collaboration from both endsThe speed gap between startups that must move fast and institutions built to move slowly
🔹 AI as glue and as a threat: the same technology that lowers the cost of integration can erode the value of the partners it connectsHow AI can boost productivity in business — and why many Italian firms are still holding back
Full transcript
What are the main benefits of collaboration between companies?
Collaboration lets companies share skills, investment, training, markets and knowledge. For smaller companies, coming together makes it possible to overcome some of the limits of scale and to access resources they could hardly develop on their own. Collaboration can also drive innovation, spread risk, open access to new markets and build new value propositions.
Why have business networks become an important instrument for SMEs?
Micro and small businesses make up a significant share of the productive system and have historically used aggregation tools such as industrial districts and consortia. Business networks are an evolution of those instruments, better suited to a context where technology, innovation and collaboration between different skill sets matter more and more.
What is the difference between the traditional consortium model and newer forms of collaboration?
The consortium emerged primarily as a way of bringing companies together, with a history tied to regulating relationships between parties working on particular parts of a production process. Business networks respond instead to the need for more flexible, more contemporary instruments, able to support collaborations built around sharing knowledge, investment, technology, markets and innovation.
Is company size still a decisive factor in competitiveness?
Size is not necessarily decisive. Small companies can develop highly specialised skills and slot them into wider ecosystems. Sharing know-how, intellectual property and other intangible assets can matter more than organisational size alone. The evolution of AI and robotics also makes it possible for small companies to access technologies that once required far larger structures.
What is the difference between collaborating to build critical mass and collaborating around open innovation?
Collaboration can aim at critical mass, increasing companies’ negotiating power and representation. In other cases the goal is different: bringing together specialised skills, knowledge and investment already made, in order to develop a new offering, product or market faster. In that second case, the value comes above all from how the parties complement one another.
What is the value of orchestration within a business ecosystem?
Orchestration means coordinating different skills, technologies and services and turning them into a coherent offering for the end customer. The value of an ecosystem does not come only from the sum of its parts, but from the ability to integrate them and make them serve a common goal. The orchestrator therefore creates value over and above what each participant produces individually.
How does the principle of orchestration apply in mobility?
In mobility, orchestration can mean bringing together different players and technologies — rental companies, insurers, telematics systems, CRM, quoting systems and other technology components. The aim is for the customer to experience the result as a single service, even though different companies sit behind the offering.
Why can open innovation accelerate innovation?
Because it lets you draw on skills and investment already available inside other organisations, rather than developing every necessary element in-house. Collaboration therefore shortens the time needed to build a new offering and combines specialist skills that would rarely sit inside a single company.
What is the main organisational effect of open innovation?
Open innovation does not necessarily remove complexity: more often it moves it. When a company integrates numerous partners and technologies, it has to develop greater organisational capability to coordinate all those elements. That is why orchestration becomes essential — it has to manage the complexity inside the ecosystem and turn it into simplicity for the customer.
How should risk be distributed within a business ecosystem?
Each participant should take on the risk attached to its own share of the investment and receive a portion of the value consistent with its contribution and the risk it carries. Sharing risk spreads investment across several parties and makes it possible to pursue initiatives that would be too risky for a single company.
How do you stop a collaboration from becoming just a client-supplier relationship?
You have to move beyond a logic where one company orders a service from another and the relationship amounts to an economic exchange. Real collaboration has to make the most of each participant’s know-how and build shared objectives. The company coordinating the ecosystem therefore has to recognise the specific value of its partners and create the conditions for them to grow together.
Is there a risk that a larger company dominates smaller ones inside a partnership?
Yes. A large company may tend to impose its own processes, models and organisational rigidities. Conversely, a smaller company may fear being crushed by the relationship and respond defensively. Either dynamic can undermine the collaboration. That is why the relationship has to be built on trust, balance and proportion between value contributed and value received.
How do you build a balanced relationship between companies of different sizes?
The first element is trust. After that, objectives have to be clarified, the business case for collaborating has to be tested, and a structure has to be found in which every participant stands to benefit. It is also important to assess compatibility between partners, work out which skills are needed, and check whether some parties should be added to or left out of the ecosystem.
Why should trust come before the contractual terms?
A contract can protect a collaboration, but it can rarely compensate for the absence of a model that genuinely works for the parties. Trust, shared objectives and a sound business case therefore have to be built before the legal instruments are defined. The contract should be the consequence of a solid collaboration model, not its starting point.
What does building a genuinely win-win collaboration mean?
It means creating a situation where every participant has a concrete reason to stay in the ecosystem. That reason may be revenue, access to skills, new markets, technology, investment or reduced risk. There also has to be a balanced relationship between what each party puts in and the value it receives.
What role does flexibility play in strategic partnerships?
Flexibility matters above all in ecosystems operating in fast-moving markets. Agreements have to provide clear rules and security while still allowing partners to adapt and develop the collaboration over time. A structure that is too rigid can stop an ecosystem evolving alongside its market.
Where should an SME with limited resources start if it wants to build strategic collaborations?
It should focus first on its own specialisation and distinctive skills. The aim is not to develop everything needed in-house, but to strengthen its own element of value and then place it inside a wider ecosystem. That way a small company can contribute a specific capability without having to carry the entire investment needed to build a new offering.
How can a small company find the ecosystems to join?
It can look for parties that perform an orchestration role and have the ability to connect different skills. It can also use the opportunities offered by chambers of commerce, working groups, science and technology parks and other local initiatives. These settings make it possible to build relationships, identify partners and discover technologies and opportunities a small company would struggle to explore alone.
Which technologies are increasing the need for collaboration?
Among those mentioned are artificial intelligence, blockchain, cybersecurity, sensor technology, robotics and quantum computing. Their growing complexity makes it hard for a single small company to develop all the necessary skills internally. Collaboration therefore makes it possible to combine different specialisations and access technologies that might otherwise be difficult to implement.
Why might technological change also reshape the traditional idea of open innovation?
The traditional model was often based on sharing knowledge between companies, universities and research centres, with each organisation then developing and commercialising what it had learned independently. Today collaboration can go further, as far as jointly building and implementing a single solution or a new product. That makes ecosystems more integrated and more oriented towards common outcomes.
Why is trust considered the first step in collaboration between companies?
Because effective collaboration requires openness, information sharing and a willingness to pool skills and resources. Entrepreneurs may naturally be inclined to protect their business and their knowledge, but excessive closure prevents them from making the most of what collaboration offers. Trust is what gradually brings those barriers down.
What dynamics can get in the way of trust between companies?
The main obstacles include fear of losing control, fear of being penalised by a stronger partner, over-protecting one’s own information and the risk of opportunistic behaviour. Differences in power and size can also create imbalance. If a company senses the relationship is not symmetrical, it may become defensive in ways that end up undermining the collaboration.
What does symmetry inside a partnership mean?
It means maintaining a balance between the value each party brings to the collaboration and what it expects to receive. Symmetry does not necessarily mean everyone contributes equally, but that the relationship between contributions, benefits and risks is perceived as fair. Where innovation is involved, that balance also has to cover how project risk is distributed.
How can the stronger partner help make a collaboration more balanced?
It can take on a larger share of the risk when it has greater resources and capability, particularly if that allows the whole ecosystem to reach a result faster. The goal is not necessarily to distribute risk identically, but in a way that is consistent with each participant’s capacity and contribution.
What does building a “current account of trust” between partners mean?
Trust can be seen as a relationship in which each party has to contribute first in order to benefit later from the other’s willingness to do the same. It is reciprocal and gradual. Trust does not eliminate problems, but it does let you address and resolve them faster when they arise.
What signals indicate that a partner is reliable?
One important signal is the willingness to share relevant information, including financial information, where that is necessary to build a shared project. A readiness to provide data on revenue, costs, economic structure or product design indicates openness and confidence in the group. Transparency, when properly protected, makes it easier to assess whether the collaboration is worthwhile.
Does trust come before or after concrete results?
Trust is built gradually. At the start, openness, transparency and a willingness to collaborate matter most. Concrete, measurable results follow and strengthen the relationship. Over time a track record also builds up: previous experience becomes a useful indicator of a partner’s future reliability.
How much do short-term results matter in consolidating a partnership?
A great deal. Being able to produce results quickly and test them on the market lets partners verify in practice whether the collaboration model works. Working towards measurable results in relatively short timeframes therefore helps build trust and creates a virtuous dynamic.
What is the relationship between trust, transparency and track record?
Transparency is the initial signal of openness, concrete results make it possible to verify that commitments are kept, and the track record built over time consolidates a partner’s reputation. Trust therefore emerges from the interaction between behaviour, results and the history of the relationship.
What role does AI play in collaborative ecosystems?
AI can make collaboration easier by reducing the cost of interfacing between different systems, processes and organisations. It can help automate activities that would otherwise require more complex integration work and speed up the connections between the different components of an ecosystem.
Can AI also be a risk for companies collaborating in an ecosystem?
Yes. AI can replace certain activities, or entire parts of a process previously handled by specialised firms. In those cases a technology that facilitates integration can simultaneously reduce the value of some of the work partners do. AI’s impact therefore has to be assessed both as an opportunity for collaboration and as a potential substitute.
How is AI actually used in collaborative processes?
It can be used to simplify and speed up processes involving many different players and services. In particular it can reduce the complexity of integrations and make it easier to build interfaces between systems that would otherwise require longer, more complex work. In that sense AI can become a new technological component of the ecosystem.
Will AI completely replace people in collaboration between companies?
Not necessarily. AI can automate and simplify many processes, but collaboration still requires people — above all for everything tied to trust, relationships, creativity and managing the relationship between organisations. Technology can reduce operational complexity, but it does not remove the need to build relationships between partners.
What opportunities does AI offer small companies?
It can give even small companies access to technological capabilities they could hardly develop alone. It can automate laborious tasks, increase productivity and let people focus more on higher-value professional work. It can also make possible new services that, without automation, would require more staff than a small company could sustain.
Which AI applications can be particularly relevant for SMEs?
Beyond generative tools, predictive applications and those based on data analysis and sensor technology can be important. These technologies can be used, for example, to monitor buildings, plant and products, or to develop more advanced services in the sectors where small companies operate.
Can AI increase the creative capacity of small companies?
It can help free up resources and time from more repetitive activities, allowing people to focus more on creativity, design and the company’s distinctive skills. The direct relationship with the customer and the ability to interpret their needs remain fundamental, particularly for small companies.
Should small companies see AI as a threat or an opportunity?
Above all as an opportunity to understand and integrate gradually. There are certainly ethical, organisational and employment-related questions, but ignoring AI is not a sustainable strategy. For smaller companies it can in fact become a way to increase productivity, develop new services and offset some of the limits tied to resources and headcount.